Final fantasy tier list: Which games reign supreme?
Ah, Final Fantasy. Just the name conjures up images of sprawling worlds, unforgettable characters, epic narratives, and some of the most emotionally resonant soundtracks in video game history. For decades, Square Enix (and previously Square) has delivered a parade of RPG masterpieces, each striving to reinvent the wheel while staying true to the series’ core spirit. But with so many mainline entries, spin-offs, and remakes, a burning question inevitably arises among fans: which ones are truly the best? Creating a definitive Final Fantasy tier list is akin to wrangling chocobos in a thunderstorm – chaotic, subjective, and bound to ruffle a few feathers. Yet, the discourse is half the fun! We’re diving deep into the crystal-laden archives to sort through the legends, the overlooked gems, and perhaps a few we’d rather not talk about, to crown the true kings and queens of the Final Fantasy universe.
The s-tier pantheon: Legends forged in crystal
Welcome to the hallowed halls of S-tier, where only the most transcendent Final Fantasy experiences reside. These are the games that not only defined generations but continue to influence RPGs today. They boast narratives that stick with you for life, characters you’d happily follow to the ends of the earth (and beyond), and gameplay mechanics that, for their time, felt utterly revolutionary. Debating which specific games sit atop this golden perch is a rite of passage for any fan, but a few usually make a compelling case for universal acclaim.
For many, Final Fantasy VII is the undisputed champion. Its gritty, cyberpunk-esque setting was a stark departure from previous fantasy worlds, its narrative tackled complex themes like environmentalism and corporate greed, and its characters, particularly Cloud Strife and Sephiroth, became cultural icons. The Materia system offered unparalleled customization, and the iconic pre-rendered backgrounds coupled with 3D models were groundbreaking. Then there’s Final Fantasy X, a masterpiece of storytelling with a truly emotional journey, stellar voice acting (a first for the series), and the addictive Sphere Grid progression. Tidus and Yuna’s love story, intertwined with the poignant struggle against Sin, is a narrative high point that still brings a tear to many an eye. Let’s not forget the SNES era’s juggernaut, Final Fantasy VI. This game delivered an ensemble cast of protagonists, each with their own compelling arc, and a narrative that dared to have the villain succeed, plunging the world into ruin. Its opera scene alone is legendary, a testament to its daring ambition and unparalleled storytelling prowess for its era. These games aren’t just good; they’re pivotal, pushing boundaries and etching themselves into the very fabric of gaming history.
A-tier contenders: Brilliant, bold, and just a whisper away
Just below the gods of S-tier lie the truly excellent, the games that are masterpieces in their own right, perhaps only missing that *one* elusive spark or having a minor quirk that prevents universal S-tier consensus. These A-tier titles still offer hundreds of hours of phenomenal gameplay, unforgettable moments, and often experiment with concepts that were ahead of their time.
Take Final Fantasy IX, for example. Often seen as a nostalgic callback to the series’ roots after the futuristic bent of VII and VIII, IX delivered a charming, whimsical world, a return to classic fantasy tropes, and arguably one of the most endearing casts in the entire series. Its active time battle (ATB) system was polished, and its story about identity and belonging resonated deeply. It’s a game bursting with heart. Then there’s Final Fantasy XII, a title that dared to completely overhaul the battle system with its “Gambit” system, allowing for unprecedented strategic control over party AI. Its vast world of Ivalice and political intrigue were absorbing, though some found its MMO-like combat and lack of a central, character-driven focus a bit polarizing. Still, its scope and ambition are undeniable. And for sheer historical significance and a remarkably strong narrative for its time, Final Fantasy IV deserves a high spot. It was one of the first RPGs to heavily focus on character drama and a more linear, story-driven approach, paving the way for future entries. Its Dark Knight Cecil’s journey of redemption is classic hero’s fare done exceptionally well.
B-tier delights: Solid adventures with their own charm
Moving into the B-tier, we find games that are genuinely good, often very enjoyable, but perhaps don’t quite hit the same stratospheric highs as their loftier counterparts. They might have a divisive mechanic, a story that doesn’t quite land for everyone, or simply didn’t innovate as profoundly. Yet, to dismiss them would be a grave mistake, as each holds a unique place in the series’ legacy and offers substantial fun.
Consider Final Fantasy VIII. Oh, the debates this game sparks! Its Junction system, which tied magic directly to stats and essentially discouraged using it, was a bold, if baffling, design choice. Coupled with a narrative that could be overly convoluted and characters like Squall and Rinoa whose romance was either adored or derided, it’s a game of extremes. However, its fantastic Guardian Force summons, iconic Triple Triad card game, and incredible soundtrack elevate it significantly. Then there’s Final Fantasy V, an unsung hero for many, largely celebrated for its incredibly deep and flexible Job System. While its story is somewhat lighter and less memorable than its peers, the sheer joy of mixing and matching abilities to create unstoppable character builds provides hundreds of hours of strategic satisfaction. And what about Final Fantasy XIII? Visually stunning, with a superb combat system that was both fast-paced and tactical, it suffered from an infamously linear opening and a story that relied heavily on external lore documents. Despite its flaws, the characters were compelling, and the satisfaction of mastering its Paradigm Shift system was immense. These games might have their quirks, but they are still solid Final Fantasy experiences worth your time.
C-tier and the curious cases: For the brave and the nostalgic
Finally, we arrive at the C-tier and beyond, a realm reserved for the polarizing, the historically significant but mechanically dated, or the games that, for various reasons, simply didn’t quite capture the series’ magic for a broad audience. It’s important to note that “C-tier” for Final Fantasy often still means “a decent game” when compared to other franchises, but perhaps not a flagship entry for this beloved series. These are the games that spark the most fervent defenses and disagreements, proving that even a “lesser” Final Fantasy still holds a special place for someone.
Final Fantasy XV, for example, is a visually stunning road trip adventure with a compelling brotherhood at its core. However, its open world felt somewhat disjointed, and its narrative, particularly in its second half, was notoriously rushed and incomplete, requiring significant post-launch DLC to tell a coherent story. For some, its real-time combat and bromance made it a modern classic; for others, it was a missed opportunity. Then we look back to the origins: Final Fantasy II and III. Historically crucial, yes, but their gameplay mechanics often haven’t aged gracefully. FFII’s skill progression, where characters improve in areas based on how often they use them (e.g., getting hit to increase HP), was innovative but could be incredibly grindy and unintuitive. FFIII introduced the Job System that FFV perfected, but its punishing difficulty and lack of modern conveniences can make it a tough sell for new players. Even the original Final Fantasy, while the genesis of it all, is a product of its time – charmingly simple but undeniably archaic by modern standards. These games are fascinating artifacts, crucial stepping stones, but often require a hefty dose of nostalgia or patience to truly appreciate today.
Conclusion
Phew! Navigating the intricate tapestry of Final Fantasy games and attempting to rank them is a colossal undertaking, fraught with peril and passionate debate. What becomes abundantly clear is that the series’ enduring appeal lies in its willingness to constantly evolve, to experiment, and to deliver unforgettable experiences across diverse worlds and characters. From the groundbreaking narratives of the S-tier to the charming quirks of the B-tier, and even the challenging historical significance of the C-tier, each entry contributes to the rich legacy of Final Fantasy. Ultimately, a “perfect” tier list is a myth, a subjective journey through personal nostalgia and individual preference. The true strength of Final Fantasy isn’t just in its peaks, but in the sheer variety and ambition of its entire catalog. So, go forth, revisit your favorites, try the ones you missed, and embrace the endless discussions. For in the world of Final Fantasy, every game, in its own way, reigns supreme for someone.
Q and A
Q1: Which Final Fantasy game is generally considered the best starting point for newcomers?
A1: Many fans recommend Final Fantasy X for its compelling, self-contained story, excellent voice acting, and relatively accessible turn-based combat system. Final Fantasy VII Remake is also a fantastic entry point if you prefer modern graphics and real-time combat, though it’s part of an ongoing story.
Q2: Are the online Final Fantasy games (XIV and XI) considered in these tier lists?
A2: Typically, tier lists like this focus on the main, single-player offline entries. However, Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn and its subsequent expansions (Heavensward, Stormblood, Shadowbringers, Endwalker) are widely regarded as having some of the best stories and content in the entire franchise, often placing them in S-tier for those who include MMOs.
Q3: What makes a Final Fantasy game “S-tier” for most fans?
A3: S-tier games usually excel in multiple areas: a deeply engaging and emotional story, memorable and well-developed characters, innovative or perfectly executed gameplay mechanics, a stunning soundtrack, and a significant cultural or historical impact on the series and genre.
Q4: Why are some older Final Fantasy games (like II or III) often ranked lower?
A4: While historically important, games like Final Fantasy II and III often suffer from archaic gameplay mechanics (e.g., FFII’s proficiency-based leveling) and less refined narratives compared to later entries. Their difficulty and lack of modern quality-of-life features can make them challenging for contemporary players to enjoy without significant patience.
Q5: Is there a consensus “worst” Final Fantasy game?
A5: While highly subjective, the original launch version of Final Fantasy XIV (often referred to as “1.0”) is almost universally considered the series’ biggest failure due to its technical issues, poor design, and uninspiring content. However, the relaunched Final Fantasy XIV: A Realm Reborn completely redeemed the title, becoming one of the most critically acclaimed MMOs ever.
| Tier | Representative Games (Example) | Key Characteristics |
|---|---|---|
| S-Tier | Final Fantasy VII, Final Fantasy X, Final Fantasy VI | Groundbreaking narrative, iconic characters, innovative gameplay, cultural impact. |
| A-Tier | Final Fantasy IX, Final Fantasy XII, Final Fantasy IV | Masterful storytelling, unique mechanics, compelling worlds, just short of universal S-tier consensus. |
| B-Tier | Final Fantasy VIII, Final Fantasy V, Final Fantasy XIII | Solid gameplay, good stories, strong individual elements but with some divisive features or flaws. |
| C-Tier and Below | Final Fantasy XV, Final Fantasy II, Final Fantasy III | Polarizing elements, dated mechanics, disjointed narratives, or requiring significant patience/nostalgia. |
Image by: Erik Mclean
https://www.pexels.com/@introspectivedsgn